In Banda and Another v Van der Spuy and Another 2013 (4) SA 77 (SCA) the owners of a house with a leaking thatched roof sold the house without disclosing the fact that the repairs to the roof had not properly rectified the defect. One of the questions was whether the sellers’ fraudulent concealment of the latent defect nullified the effect of a voetstoots clause.
It was held that the fact that the sellers were aware of only one of the factors that caused the leakage, did not affect the fact that their conduct was fraudulent and their fraudulent conduct resulted in the forfeiture of the protection of the voetstoots clause in respect of the latent defect.
The court also held that as to damages the buyers were entitled to the difference between the purchase price of the house and its value with the defective roof.
“I have successfully used Shaun in commercial arbitration, corporate/commercial law matters and in the arena of insolvency law, in all of which he is well accomplished.”
- Grant Davidson [businessman for three decades]
“Shaun is well versed in business and the laws governing general business, but particularly the information technology industry and Shaun is professional and loyal to a fault”
– Tinus Neethling [managing director of Rorotika Technologies]
“Shaun is imaginative, hardworking, accommodating and honest – Shaun acted for Pirelli Tyres before, while and after I was the managing director of the company, dealing with all legal matters, including the drafting and enforcement of various types of contracts and other litigious matters.”
- Ashley Cooper [former managing director of Pirelli Tyres]
“Shaun’s service is efficient, honest and of the highest professional standard – Shaun acted for the construction companies of which I was the financial director/officer, dealing with all legal matters related to the construction industry, including litigation and the drafting and enforcement of construction related contracts and negotiations.”
- Carel van Reenen [former financial director of Stocks Roads]
“Shaun Nel’s services were consistently of the highest ethical & professional standards I experienced in my near four decade banking career – Shaun having acted for the bank in enforcing
lending agreements, drafting bank related agreements and giving guidance on various aspects involving banking.”
- William King Powell [retired Standard Bank manager]